Tuesday, December 27, 2005
[695] Of Arabs aren't Malays and Malays aren't Arabs
For the last few days, I've been out and about in some place south of Kuala Lumpur. Apart from falling off a bike in a very fashionable way and severely lacked stamina, I overheard a conversation between two Muslim Malay males, both were draped in Arabic dressing. The conversation was about westernized Malays. I wasn't sure if they were talking about me in particular though I was wearing a Michigan cap, a cargo pant and a bright shirt while my mp3 player was valiantly trying to entertain me until it ran out of juice. And it died out exactly when the conversation started to get interesting. Before that, I didn't eavesdrop on purpose - situation forced me to be where I was.

One of the two friends was lamenting on how the Malay society is rapidly being westernized at the expense of the Malay culture . The person went on further by stating sooner or later, Malay culture would die out with morality and god phrased out by burgers and pizzas, g-strings and bikinis.

The other one agreed and began lambasting how inferior western cultures and moral are compared to Islam's. It was odd how they used the term Malay and Islamic culture interchangeably. Soon enough, as I followed the conversation quietly while tending to my cool wound, I realized that the Malay culture they were talking about was really Arabic culture. They made no distinction between Malay, Arab and Islam.

I rolled my eyes upon that discovery and felt how oxymoronic the situation at hand was. They were talking about the Malays abandoning Malay culture while they themselves were wearing something not Malay but entirely Arabic. Thanks to that, hypocrites is the best noun to describe the two Arabized Malays. I think, they would grasp very well what the word munafiqun means.

I'm no sociologist but I learned long ago that culture is a way of life. It doesn't matter how a person lives his or her life but however they choose to live it, it's their choice and that's their culture. In essence, they choose their culture and indeed, I choose my own.

I'm a Muslim Malay. At the same time, my culture is a hodgepodge of many cultures that I've had the luxury of interacting with. A hybrid culture if I may. Furthermore, I take that culture isn't a static intangible entity. It changes and adapts to time, just like how many of us do. This is especially true to hybrid cultures.

As a result, I appreciate diversity and am no purist. While no purist, I do hate how English words are being imported with impunity into the Malay language (check also Hijacking Bahasa Melayu at theCicak). If George Orwell were a Malay, he would agree with me since he did write that one should never use a foreign phrase, a scientific word, or a jargon word if you can think of an everyday English equivalent in Politics and the English Language. But that is another topic to be harped at, at another time.

Due to my hybrid culture, I find the conversation mildly offensive. They were deriding part of my culture while turning a blind eye on their, through their other eye, sin. I would have offered my opinion to them about their clothing but with stamina low and knee in uncomfortable pain, I had no appetite for a potentially heated discussion on culture.

While giving the topic a thought, I realized that this hypocrisy is not exclusively the two Arabized fellows' problem. This Arabization is spreading fast and affecting Malaysian culture. Look no farther than Putrajaya. Notice how Arabic the city actually is? Where is the Malay in it? The Chinese or the Indian in it? The Dayak or the Iban, the Minang, the Bugis? Where's the Malaysian in it?

Then, look at PAS efforts to Arabize Terengganu and Kelantan. One time, I clearly remember that they banned wayang kulit, Mak Yong and other Malay heritage in the name of Islam. They even removed a giant turtle sculpture in Kuala Terengganu for the sake of Islam. As far as I care to remember, the sculpture was synonymous with Kuala Terengganu. A deduction - PAS banned the Malay culture and then encourages Arabic in place of cultural vacumn that PAS had created!

In reality, these Arabized Malays just hate everything that isn't Arabic, including things that are Malay. Here, by no mean I'm deriding the Arabs. Arabic culture is part of me. If I were dismissing Arabic culture, I would be dismissing mine too and that wouldn't be right. I'm merely debunking the two guys' thinking and their kind.

I'm quite liberal on culture and hence, I don't mind if one insists into living like the Arabs. I myself, at risk of redundancy, have said earlier that I choose my culture and one may choose his or hers own too as I've chosen mine.

Nevertheless, if you are the two fellows whom deride other Malays as abandoning Malay culture in favor of western's one, please take a look in a mirror. Before expressing that idea, please notice that you're abandoning Malay for Arabic. Arabic culture is not Malay and Malay is not Arabic. Being a Muslim isn't about being an Arab either.
09:55 EST | (9) Comments

I am not a malay but am married to one. I agree fully with your thoughts and its sad that Malays are losing their beautiful culture and traditions all int he name of Islam which is actually Arabanisation.

By Adam, at 27 December, 2005 22:05  


those two are nothing but a bunch of muslim radicals and hypocrites. dressing up in jubahs or tudungs does not make one hollier than the rest.

in every religion, you get this religious zealots who think and feel that they are more righteous and holly. always telling others on how to lead their lives because they feel that their way of life is the benchmark for others to follow.

"why remove the splinter in your brother's eye when there is a plank in your own eyes"

By wan tan mee walla, at 27 December, 2005 22:36  


lots of people like that running around nowadays..

By Desparil, at 27 December, 2005 22:56  


What I hate most is how these people think their brand of the Malay culture and Islam is apt for the rest of the Malay race particularly in Malaysia...

By Nizam Zakaria, at 28 December, 2005 04:21  


Well said _earth! :)

I agree with you totally. Malaysia currently is being slowly 'Arabised', especially at the expense of the Malay culture, due to the fallicy that Islam and the Arabic culture is synonymous, when they're not. Culture and religion are two separate things.

By sigma, at 28 December, 2005 07:43  


_earth, lot of people (any place in this world) could only envy your example of course not because Michigan cap but things you say, fine ethics, wide views dialectic and analytic approach.
Keep on, follow that line, that's the culture this planet needs the most.

By Boris , at 28 December, 2005 17:30  


Mr Earth , u r right on d money, man!Those Saddam-wannabe Malays are one hell of a confused lot. But again, the root problem lies in the weak racial identity of us Malays. Imagine our Constitution also defines a Malay as professing the religion of Islam as a prequisite for being "Malay". Whereas our history books unproportionately concentrate on the Malacca sultanate, whose reign was hardly a century.IMHO, we should ascribe to the larger empires of Sriwijaya & Majapahit hence a Nusantara approach of being "Malay". Which effectively means that a Hindu guy in Bali is as much a Malay as another Catholic,Tagalog-speaker in Luzon (hey check out Malay pride in Philippines). On a good day, we may include the Merinas race of Madagascar. Heck, we could even lay ancestry claim to our seafaring forefathers which founded Easter Island! So there, there's no two-way about it, we either remain heavily Arab-centric as per present day, or re-claim Malay race pride independent of religion.

By Anonymous, at 29 December, 2005 21:54  


That is so true _earth.

By NSDS3HvLDjJd, at 01 January, 2006 20:23  


Dear Earthinc

Most Malay communities seems confused of either being Malay Muslim or like Arab Muslim. He have our own culture. The ARAB have their own and our culture and their culture is different. What really irritate me of those so called religious Malay who didn't realize of being Malay is not being Arab. What is so holy of following Arab culture? I am strongly opposed the Arabization of Malay since I have been in Arab countries and I found out that their culture sometimes doesn't resemble any Islamic values. These ARABs are mostly stupid and arrogant and some of the culture is depicted during early Jahiliah. So those so called Malay-Muslim-Arabized should stop being Arab and instead be a real Malay.

By Anonymous, at 23 January, 2006 05:11  


                   
nav 
home
about
gallery
archives
site feed
blogroll 
Ada apa dengan ShinShin
Adam Smith Institute
the aseanist
Ann Arbor Is Overrated
Bibliobibuli
The Big Picture
broken porcelain
The Challenge
theCicak
Daily Dose of Imagery
Daily Kos
EnviroSpin Watch
Environmental and Urban Economics
FerShithah
Games Design Art Culture
Greenpeace Weblogs
Ijat
Jun
James in Athens
John Howard: Prime Minister
Laputan Logic
Lim Kit Siang
Low Culture
MGoBlog
Mike Ng
MobuzzTV
Nik Nazmi
Overheard in Ann Arbor
Politics 101 Malaysia
Primate Noise
RealClimate
Samizdata.net
Screenshots
Seat of the Revolution
Le spectateur
Taiwan Tank
Travellers' Tales
The Truth Laid Bear
Under These Skies
Wikipedia Blog
WorldChanging
michigan 
University of Michigan
LSA
Economics
University Library
Solar Car Team
Field Hockey Club
Michigan Student Assembly
Environmental Justice Group
Malaysian Students' Association
newsfeed & misc 
AP
BBC
Bernama
Bloomberg
Detroit Free Press
ENN
ESPN Soccernet
Malaysiakini
Michigan Daily
The Michigan Independent
MLive
New York Times
New Straits Times Press
Reuters
Space.com
The Star (Malaysia)
The Straits Times
Telegraph.co.uk
Wired
AFC Ajax Amsterdam
Ajax USA
Bazuki Muhammad - The Fotofolio
Earth Day Network
Earth First!
Earth Island Institute
Earth Liberation Front
Environmental Defense
Greenpeace
Grist Magazine
Infinite Matrix
National Geographic Society
ReCom.org
Renewable Energy
Seirra Club
US Green Party
UEFA
Utopia
United Angels
Utopia Temple
Thottbot
Wikipedia
World of Warcraft
World Wide Fund for Nature
bs 
Powered by Blogger Powered by Blogger
Creative Commons License

Listed on BlogShares


Google
Web maddruid.com


Template designed by
__earth
or in the duller real life,
Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams
(that's me not you). All media published here are mine and licensed under Creative Commons, unless stated otherwise. I did not create all the icons under Et Cetera except The __earthinc's. I edited Blogger and Atom icons.

Mail me at
mnoorsha [at] umich
[dot] edu


The __earthinc 2001-2005.


All your base are belong to us. Us, means, me, __earth. So, Bow to me, puny human!